10 Questions to Ask Before Hiring a Roofer

Before you hire a roofer, ask about their insurance, who will actually do the work, which trade bodies they belong to, what similar jobs they've finished, how they diagnosed the problem, what the quote includes, how they'll work safely, whether Building Regulations apply, what guarantee you'll get in writing, and how payment and timing will work. Each question below comes with what a good answer sounds like and what should make you pause.

You need to do this checking yourself because roofing isn't a licensed trade in the UK. There is no general statutory roofing licence, so anyone can advertise as a roofer. Voluntary schemes, qualifications, insurance and a clear paper trail are what separate a dependable firm from a risky one, and most of it can be sorted with one phone call and a few online lookups.

The 10 Questions at a Glance

# Ask A good answer Pause if you hear
1 Are you insured? Certificate emailed, in date, covers roof work 'Yes, I'll dig it out later'
2 Who will be on my roof? Named crew or site lead; subcontractors disclosed Vagueness about who is coming
3 Which schemes do you belong to? Named bodies you can look up Logos with no membership details
4 Can I see similar jobs? Dated photos, references, local examples Only stock images
5 What's wrong, and how do you know? Photos, a specific cause, repair and replace options 'It all needs doing' with no evidence
6 What does the quote cover? Itemised, in writing, extras priced up front A single line total
7 How will you work safely? Scaffold or edge protection, a method statement 'A ladder will do' for a big job
8 Do Building Regulations apply? A clear answer, who handles it, a certificate 'Nobody bothers with that'
9 What's the guarantee? In writing: scope, length, who stands behind it Verbal promises only
10 How and when do I pay? Staged payments, start date, waste removal Large cash deposit, pressure to start today

Put the same ten questions to every firm you contact. Council consumer guidance recommends getting at least three quotes and checking exactly what each price covers, and identical questions turn a gut feeling into something you can compare.

1. Are you insured, and can I see the certificate?

Yes, and ask to see it rather than taking their word. A roofer should hold public liability insurance, which responds if their work damages your property or injures someone else. A firm that employs staff must also carry employers' liability insurance by law.

Roofing carries obvious risks for the building: a slate dropped through a conservatory roof, a scaffold pole against a parked car, rain getting into a stripped loft. Without cover, you could end up chasing a roofer personally for the repair bill.

When the certificate arrives, check four things. The company name should match the one on the quote. The policy should be in date. It should cover roof work or work at height. And the limit of cover should be sensible for a job on your type of home. Ask for a copy by email so it sits with your records.

Sole traders with no employees don't need employers' liability cover, but public liability is still worth asking for. If the answer is that it's 'in the van', or the certificate is promised and never arrives, treat that as your answer.

2. Who will be on my roof, and who supervises them?

Ask whether the people doing the work are the firm's own employees or subcontractors, and who will lead the job on site. Subcontracting isn't automatically a problem, but it changes who is accountable, whose insurance applies, and whether the person who quoted is the person who checks the finished work.

Useful follow-ups: will the same crew start and finish the job, and who is your point of contact on the day? If part of the work is subcontracted (scaffolding often is), is that business insured, and does the firm's guarantee still cover it?

JDH Roofing describes its team as fully vetted, insured and qualified roofers. Ask any firm you're considering to show you the same, not just say it.

A straight answer sounds like names and roles. An evasive one sounds like 'we've got lads who do it'.

3. Which trade bodies and qualifications do you hold, and can I check them?

Ask which schemes they belong to, then look them up yourself. The UK has no general statutory licence for roofers, so membership of recognised schemes and relevant qualifications are the nearest thing to independent evidence of competence.

There are several places to check. TrustMark is the government-endorsed quality mark for trades in and around the home, and you can search it by postcode. The National Federation of Roofing Contractors (NFRC) keeps a searchable list of members. Competent Person schemes for roofing matter too, because their members can certify Building Regulations compliance.

Logos are easy to copy onto a website, so the lookup matters more than the badge. Check, too, that the registration covers roofing specifically. JDH Roofing displays SPRA, City & Guilds, Polygomma, FSB and MyBuilder badges on its website. As with any firm, the sensible step is to confirm each one with the organisation concerned.

4. Can you show me similar jobs you've completed recently?

Ask for dated photos of comparable work and contact details for one or two recent customers. Roofs differ more than people expect. Lead flashings around a chimney, natural slate, interlocking concrete tiles and a bonded flat roof membrane are different skills, and a firm that excels at one may be less practised at another.

Before-and-after photos taken from the same angle are the most convincing, especially from the last year or two. Where the owner agrees, a finished roof you can see from the street beats any photo.

When you read online reviews, look for patterns rather than star ratings. How a firm handled its one difficult job usually tells you more than a page of five-star notes.

5. What exactly is wrong with my roof, and how do you know?

Ask the roofer to explain the cause, show you the evidence and set out your options. A good diagnosis names a location and a mechanism: failed flashing where the roof meets a chimney, slipped tiles above a valley, a split in a flat roof's membrane. It is backed by dated photos.

Water rarely drops straight down from the hole to the stain. It can run along felt, battens or rafters before it appears on a ceiling, so a stain above the sofa doesn't tell you where the fault is. That is why an inspection from outside and from inside the loft matters.

Follow up with two questions: 'What is the minimum that fixes this safely?' and 'What would you recommend, and why?' A roofer who can describe both a repair and a roof replacement, with reasons, is handing you a decision. One who says the whole roof needs replacing, with no photos, is handing you a sales pitch.

6. What does the quote cover, and what happens if you find more problems?

Ask for a written, itemised quote that says what's included, what's excluded and how any extra work will be priced. A one-line total gives you nothing to compare and nothing to hold anyone to.

Look for scaffolding or access equipment; named materials; underlay or membrane; battens; flashings and lead; ridge and hip details; fascias, soffits and guttering if they're part of the job; waste removal; and VAT.

Then ask the question most people forget: 'If you open the roof and find rotten battens or damaged timber, what happens?' Hidden decay can't always be seen until the covering comes off. A fair quote gives a rate per batten or per metre, or agrees that you'll be told and asked before any extra work starts.

JDH Roofing says its pricing is transparent, with no hidden costs. That's a good benchmark to hold every quote against.

7. How will you work safely, and how will you protect my property?

Ask how they'll get onto the roof, what stops people and materials falling, and who is responsible for safety on site. The Health and Safety Executive (HSE) says all work on roofs is highly dangerous and that almost one in five deaths in construction involves roof work.

HSE guidance says sloping roofs require scaffolding to stop people or materials falling from the edge. For flat roofs it points to edge protection such as a double guardrail and toeboard.

For you, that turns into practical questions. Is scaffold included in the price? How will the open roof be covered overnight if rain is forecast? How will your windows, garden, car and neighbours be protected from falling debris? A full re-roof done from ladders alone is a warning sign.

8. Does this job need Building Regulations approval, and who handles it?

Ask for a clear answer and who will deal with it. Re-roofing often needs approval in England, particularly when the covering changes (slate to heavier concrete tile, for example) or when insulation or ventilation is altered.

There are two routes to compliance. You can apply to your local authority building control, or use a roofer registered with a Competent Person scheme, who can self-certify the work and arrange your certificate. Keep that certificate. Buyers' solicitors commonly ask for evidence of compliance when a house is sold.

9. What guarantee do I get, in writing?

Ask for the guarantee in writing, covering what is included, for how long, and who pays if the firm no longer exists. A verbal 'ten years' means little if it isn't recorded.

There are usually three layers. The roofer's workmanship guarantee covers how the job was done. A manufacturer's product guarantee covers materials such as a flat roof membrane or tiles. Separately, your legal rights under the Consumer Rights Act 2015 require services to be carried out with reasonable care and skill.

A guarantee is only as good as the business behind it. JDH Roofing has been working in Yorkshire for over 16 years, which gives you a track record to check.

10. How and when do I pay, when will you start, and who clears the waste?

Agree payment stages, start and finish dates, weather arrangements and waste removal in writing before you give the go-ahead.

  • Payment: Keep any deposit modest and tied to materials, pay in stages as work is completed, and hold the final payment until you've inspected the finished job. A bank transfer leaves a record; a large cash payment up front leaves none.
  • Timing and weather: A roof shouldn't be left open to rain. Ask how it will be covered overnight and how delays will be communicated.
  • Waste: Ask whether waste removal is included and whether the firm is a registered waste carrier.
  • Your rights: If you agree work in your own home, you generally have a 14-day cooling-off period to cancel and get a refund (Citizens Advice). Be wary of anyone who pushes you to start immediately.

How to Compare Three Quotes Side by Side

Draw a simple grid with the firms across the top and these rows down the side: scaffold, named materials, underlay or membrane, flashings, waste removal, guarantee length, payment terms and start date. Every blank cell is somewhere a price difference could be hiding.

Decide on clarity and credibility, not price alone. The firm that answered all ten questions plainly, put the answers in writing and was relaxed about being checked has usually earned the job even when it isn't the cheapest.

What If My Roof Is Leaking Right Now?

You can shorten this process in an emergency, but not skip it. Move belongings, catch the water, photograph the damage for your home insurer and call a firm that offers emergency call-outs. JDH Roofing runs a 24-hour emergency service. Stay off the roof yourself.

Still ask three quick questions: are you insured, what will it cost before you start, and is this a temporary fix or the permanent repair?

What to Do Next

Write the ten questions down and send them to each firm before the survey. The roofers who answer plainly, back their answers in writing and are happy to be checked are the ones to shortlist.

If you'd like to put them to JDH Roofing, you can call 01924 497540 or 07522 052151, email info@jdhroofing.co.uk, or use the online form, which the team aims to answer within an hour. For leaks that can't wait, our 24-hour emergency service is available.

Contact JDH Roofing for a Quote

“From minor repairs to complete roof installations”

Follow us